800+ to be liquidated, but PLN 200,000. PLN per child? A controversial proposal by experts

The end of the era of simple social transfers? Jagiellonian Club experts propose a radical turn in state policy. Instead of monthly payments that are “eaten” by inflation, parents would receive a huge start-up amount. The project assumes the liquidation of flagship programs of the current and previous governments in order to pay up to PLN 200,000 for each child.

The current model of family support in Poland was based on permanent transfers. The 800+ program has become the foundation of home budgets, and recently it was joined by the so-called “grandma's”. However, the latest expert analysis sheds new light on the effectiveness of these solutions. The proposal is shocking: complete abolition of current benefits in favor of one powerful capital.

200,000 instead of small transfers

Instead of payments dispersed over time, the state would guarantee each newborn citizen a capital of PLN 200,000. zloty. This is an amount that would not, however, go directly to parents for any expenses.

Key assumptions of the new system:

• Liquidation of 800 plus and “granny”. These programs would cease to exist in their current form, freeing billions of zlotys in the budget.
• Future Fund: Funds would be pooled in individual accounts and invested to protect them against inflation – a phenomenon that drastically reduced the real value of existing benefits.
• Targeted Spending: Parents could use this money for specific purposes: education, health care or own contribution for the child's first apartment.

Why do experts say the current system is failing?

Analysts point to a “transfer trap”. Although 800+ is a huge burden on state finances, its impact on demography turned out to be negligible. Moreover, monthly cash is often consumed on an ongoing basis, not building lasting financial security for the young generation (the exception are family bonds, which can be purchased by parents receiving 800+).

Introduction 200 thousand PLN per child would be a “safety” and real starting capital, which, unlike current programs, would actually provide a chance for a better start in adulthood.

Will the budget support it?

Experts argue that the reform is budget-neutral – it involves reallocating funds that are already being spent, but in an ineffective manner. However, for millions of Polish families this would mean a revolution and the need to completely reorganize household finances.

prepared by COGS

Source: